The Best Cybersecurity Services for Insurance Companies in 2025

Insurance companies are prime targets for cyberattacks. The nature of the business requires collecting and storing vast amounts of sensitive client data, from Social Security numbers and health records to financial information. This makes insurers a high-value target for threat actors seeking to exploit personally identifiable information (PII) for financial gain. A successful breach can lead to staggering financial losses, severe regulatory penalties, and irreparable damage to a firm’s reputation. For these reasons, selecting the right cybersecurity services for insurance companies is not just an IT decision—it's a critical business imperative.

Navigating the complex landscape of security providers can be challenging. The ideal partner understands the unique regulatory pressures and operational risks facing the insurance industry. They must provide a robust defense against sophisticated threats while ensuring compliance with standards like the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) and the NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulation. This guide offers a practical review of leading providers, evaluating them on their industry expertise, compliance support, and service capabilities to help you make an informed, ROI-focused decision. Understanding the difference between internet safety and cybersecurity is the first step toward building a resilient defense.

Why Insurance Companies Need Specialized Cybersecurity

The insurance sector faces a unique combination of high-stakes data protection requirements and stringent regulatory oversight. A generic security solution is insufficient to address these distinct challenges. Effective cybersecurity for insurers is built on a deep understanding of the industry's specific risk profile and compliance obligations.

• Regulatory Compliance: The industry is governed by strict data protection laws, including the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) and the NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulation (23 NYCRR 500). Non-compliance can result in heavy fines and legal action, making cybersecurity insurance compliance services essential.
• Sensitive Data Protection: Insurers hold a treasure trove of confidential data. Protecting this information against theft and misuse is fundamental to the business and a primary focus of any effective insurance cybersecurity services.
• Maintaining Business Continuity: Cyberattacks like ransomware can disrupt core operations, from claims processing to policy underwriting. A robust security posture ensures that business can continue with minimal interruption during and after an incident.
• Third-Party Risk Management: The insurance ecosystem relies on a network of agents, brokers, and technology vendors. Each third party represents a potential security vulnerability that must be managed through comprehensive vendor risk assessments.
• Preserving Customer Trust: An insurer's reputation is built on security and trust. A data breach can quickly erode client confidence and brand loyalty, impacting long-term profitability and market position.

The High Cost of a Security Incident

The financial and operational impact of a data breach in the insurance and financial services sector is significant. The data underscores the importance of proactive investment in security to mitigate these risks before they materialize.

• The average cost of a data breach for a US-based financial services company now exceeds $5.9 million.
• Implementing multi-factor authentication (MFA) is a simple but powerful measure that can prevent over 99.9% of account compromise attacks.
• The US insurance industry reports thousands of data breach incidents to regulators annually.

How We Evaluated These Cybersecurity Providers

Our selection process focused on identifying providers that deliver tangible value and demonstrate a clear understanding of the insurance industry's needs. We used a set of practical criteria to ensure the featured services are equipped to handle the sector's unique security and compliance challenges.

• Insurance Industry Experience: We prioritized providers with a proven track record of serving financial institutions and a deep understanding of the insurance sector's operational and regulatory environment.
• Compliance & Audit Support: The services selected demonstrate expertise in helping clients meet regulatory requirements (GLBA, NYDFS) and prepare for audits like SOC 2 Type II.
• Comprehensive Service Offerings: We evaluated providers on the breadth of their services, including Managed Detection and Response (MDR), vulnerability assessments, risk management, and security awareness training.
• Market Reputation & Reviews: Selections were informed by client case studies, industry recognition, and independent reviews from platforms like G2, Clutch, and Cloudtango.

Top 10 Cybersecurity Services for Insurance Companies

Choosing a cybersecurity partner is a strategic decision that directly impacts your firm's resilience, compliance, and reputation. The following providers offer a range of services tailored to the specific needs of the insurance industry, from comprehensive managed security to specialized compliance and threat intelligence.

Cortavo

Managed IT & Cybersecurity Provider

Cortavo offers an all-in-one managed services platform that combines cybersecurity, IT support, connectivity, and hardware into a single, flat-fee subscription. This model is designed to give insurance companies predictable costs and access to a comprehensive suite of tools without the complexity of managing multiple vendors. Their services include 24/7 help desk support, proactive threat monitoring, endpoint security, and compliance assistance. By bundling essential IT functions with robust security measures, Cortavo simplifies technology management, allowing insurance firms to focus on core business operations while ensuring their infrastructure is secure, compliant, and efficient for onsite, hybrid, and remote teams.

Core Strength: Provides a fully integrated, flat-fee managed IT and cybersecurity solution for predictable budgeting and simplified vendor management.

Best For: Small to mid-sized insurance firms seeking a comprehensive, cost-effective partner for all their technology and security needs.

Pro Tip: Leverage their vCIO services for strategic planning to align your technology roadmap with business goals.

CrowdStrike

Endpoint Security & MDR Provider

CrowdStrike is a leader in cloud-native endpoint protection, threat intelligence, and managed threat hunting. Its Falcon platform uses sophisticated AI and behavioral analysis to stop breaches before they can cause damage. For insurance companies, this means powerful, real-time protection for every device—from servers to employee laptops—that accesses sensitive policyholder data. Their Managed Detection and Response (MDR) service, Falcon Complete, provides 24/7 monitoring and response from an elite team of security experts, effectively acting as an extension of your in-house team to neutralize threats quickly and efficiently, ensuring business continuity.

Core Strength: Delivers market-leading endpoint detection and response (EDR) powered by a vast threat intelligence graph.

Best For: Insurance firms of all sizes needing best-in-class endpoint security and expert-led managed threat hunting.

Pro Tip: Use the Falcon platform's visibility features to identify and mitigate risks across your entire IT environment.

Arctic Wolf

Managed Detection & Response (MDR) Provider

Arctic Wolf provides a security operations solution delivered through its concierge security model. Each client is assigned a dedicated team of security experts who act as trusted advisors, helping to tailor the service to the firm's specific risk profile and compliance needs. This is particularly valuable for insurance companies navigating complex regulations like GLBA and NYDFS. The platform offers 24/7 monitoring, managed detection and response, and vulnerability assessments, all aimed at proactively identifying and neutralizing threats. Their hands-on approach helps bridge the cybersecurity skills gap many organizations face, providing enterprise-grade security operations as a service.

Core Strength: Offers a unique concierge delivery model that provides personalized, expert guidance on security operations.

Best For: Mid-sized insurance companies that need a dedicated security team without the overhead of hiring one internally.

Pro Tip: Schedule regular check-ins with your concierge team to review security posture and address compliance questions.

Rapid7

Vulnerability Management & SIEM Provider

Rapid7’s Insight platform offers a suite of tools for vulnerability management, application security, and security information and event management (SIEM). Their InsightIDR solution provides a powerful cloud-based SIEM that simplifies threat detection and response by collecting and analyzing data from across the IT environment. For insurance companies, this means enhanced visibility into potential threats and streamlined compliance reporting. Rapid7's expertise in vulnerability management helps firms proactively identify and patch security weaknesses before they can be exploited, a critical component of meeting regulatory requirements and protecting sensitive client data.

Core Strength: Excels in vulnerability management and user-friendly SIEM for comprehensive threat detection and response.

Best For: Insurance firms needing to consolidate security tools and gain unified visibility across their entire technology stack.

Pro Tip: Use InsightVM's prioritization features to focus remediation efforts on the most critical vulnerabilities first.

Palo Alto Networks

Network & Cloud Security Provider

Palo Alto Networks is a global cybersecurity leader offering a broad portfolio of solutions, including next-generation firewalls and cloud security. Their Prisma Cloud platform is particularly relevant for insurance companies undergoing digital transformation and moving operations to the cloud. It provides comprehensive security and compliance coverage for applications, data, and the entire cloud-native technology stack—from development to deployment. This helps insurers innovate securely, ensuring that new digital services are built with data protection and regulatory compliance in mind from the start, reducing the risk of breaches in complex, multi-cloud environments.

Core Strength: Provides a comprehensive, integrated security platform for network, cloud, and endpoint protection.

Best For: Large insurance enterprises with complex hybrid and multi-cloud environments requiring unified security policies.

Pro Tip: Consolidate security vendors with their platform to simplify management and improve your overall security posture.

Secureworks

Managed Security Services Provider (MSSP)

With decades of experience, Secureworks offers deep expertise in managed security and threat intelligence. Their Taegis platform combines advanced analytics, machine learning, and human intelligence to detect and respond to threats across endpoint, network, and cloud environments. For insurance companies, Secureworks provides the assurance of 24/7 monitoring by seasoned security analysts who understand the threat landscape of the financial services industry. Their services help firms mature their security programs, improve threat visibility, and meet stringent compliance mandates by leveraging one of the industry's most respected threat intelligence units.

Core Strength: Leverages decades of experience and a powerful threat intelligence platform for managed detection and response.

Best For: Insurance firms looking for a mature, battle-tested managed security partner with deep industry expertise.

Pro Tip: Utilize their threat intelligence reports to stay ahead of emerging threats targeting the financial sector.

Mandiant

Incident Response & Threat Intelligence

Now part of Google Cloud, Mandiant is renowned for its elite incident response services and in-depth threat intelligence. While they offer proactive services, their primary value for many insurance companies lies in their unparalleled ability to respond to and remediate complex cyberattacks. Their consultants are often called in to handle the most sophisticated breaches. Engaging Mandiant for proactive services like readiness assessments and threat hunting can help insurance firms bolster their defenses based on frontline knowledge of attacker tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs), ensuring they are prepared for advanced threats.

Core Strength: Unmatched expertise in incident response and frontline threat intelligence derived from investigating major breaches.

Best For: Large insurance carriers needing to test their defenses or requiring expert assistance during a critical security incident.

Pro Tip: Engage them for a compromise assessment to uncover hidden threats within your network.

Proofpoint

Email Security & Compliance Specialist

As email remains a primary vector for cyberattacks like phishing and business email compromise (BEC), Proofpoint's focus on protecting people is highly relevant for the insurance industry. Their solutions secure email, social media, and mobile devices, preventing attacks before they reach employees. For insurance companies, their advanced threat protection and compliance capabilities are critical. They offer email archiving and supervision tools that help firms meet regulatory requirements for data retention and oversight, providing a comprehensive defense against both external threats and internal compliance risks centered around communication channels.

Core Strength: Specializes in people-centric security, offering best-in-class protection for email and other communication channels.

Best For: Insurance firms focused on mitigating human-centric risks like phishing and ensuring email compliance.

Pro Tip: Implement their security awareness training to turn your employees into a strong line of defense.

Tenable

Exposure Management Provider

Tenable specializes in exposure management, helping organizations understand and reduce their cyber risk across the entire attack surface. Their platform, Tenable One, provides comprehensive visibility into vulnerabilities across IT infrastructure, cloud environments, and web applications. For insurance companies, this continuous monitoring is essential for maintaining a strong security posture and demonstrating compliance. By identifying and prioritizing vulnerabilities based on threat context, Tenable enables security teams to focus their resources on fixing the issues that pose the greatest risk to sensitive policyholder data and critical business systems.

Core Strength: Provides comprehensive visibility and risk-based prioritization for vulnerability and exposure management.

Best For: Insurance companies needing to build a proactive, risk-based vulnerability management program to reduce their attack surface.

Pro Tip: Integrate Tenable with your ticketing system to streamline the remediation workflow for identified vulnerabilities.

Coalition

Cyber Insurance & Security Provider

Coalition offers a unique model by combining comprehensive cyber insurance with proactive cybersecurity services. They provide policyholders with a suite of free tools and services designed to help prevent incidents from happening in the first place. This includes continuous security monitoring, expert recommendations, and rapid response services. For insurance companies, partnering with or learning from Coalition's model can be insightful. Their approach directly links a strong security posture to better insurance outcomes, creating a powerful incentive for businesses to actively manage their cyber risk and demonstrate the ROI of security investments.

Core Strength: Uniquely combines cyber insurance coverage with proactive cybersecurity tools and services to actively reduce risk.

Best For: Firms looking for an integrated solution that ties security posture directly to insurance coverage and cost.

Pro Tip: Use their free risk assessment tools to get an external view of your security posture.

How to Get Started with Cortavo

Engaging with a managed cybersecurity provider should be a straightforward process. We've designed our workflow to be simple and transparent, getting you from initial contact to full protection quickly.

1. Submit your IT needs (quick online form)
2. Get a consultation to match the right plan for your team size and goals
3. Receive a flat-fee managed IT plan (cybersecurity, support, connectivity, cost management)
4. Onboard quickly with certified experts, 24/7 help desk, and ongoing technology support

Why Choose Cortavo?

Our approach is built to deliver peace of mind and predictable results. We focus on providing comprehensive, integrated solutions that allow you to focus on your business.

• Seamless IT management for onsite, hybrid, and remote workplaces
• Transparent, flat-fee plans with predictable costs
• Comprehensive services: cybersecurity, help desk, connectivity, hardware, and cost management
• Peace of mind: recognized as a top managed service provider by G2, Cloudtango, and Clutch

Conclusion

For insurance companies, cybersecurity is not an optional IT expense but a foundational component of business strategy, essential for survival and growth. The risks associated with a data breach—from regulatory fines to loss of customer trust—are too significant to ignore. Partnering with a specialized provider mitigates these risks, ensures compliance with complex regulations, and protects the invaluable trust you have built with your clients. A managed services approach offers a predictable, cost-effective way to access enterprise-grade security expertise and technology. To build a resilient defense for your firm, it is crucial to invest in the right cybersecurity services for insurance companies. Let's talk! 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)